An insurer’s estimate can run twenty pages of codes, abbreviations and decimals. It’s tempting to flip to the last page, see the number and either accept it or get angry. A better approach is to read it the way an appraiser does: section by section, line by line, asking whether each entry matches what actually happened to your property.
The layout most estimates follow
Most carriers price claims in Xactimate or similar software, so the format is fairly consistent:
- Header: policyholder, claim number, date of loss, type of loss, price list used (region and month).
- Areas: the estimate is broken into rooms or roof slopes, each with its own measurements.
- Line items: each row has a description, quantity, unit, unit price, tax, replacement cost, depreciation and actual cash value.
- Summary: totals by coverage, deductible, prior payments and net claim.
Check the header first. A price list from the wrong region or a month well before the repair can understate costs across every line.
Quantities: measure before you argue
Most disputes start with quantities. Compare the room dimensions and roof squares with your own measurements or your contractor’s. Roofs are where small differences grow quickly: a missed dormer or a wrong pitch changes shingles, underlayment, drip edge and labor all at once. Our roof squares and pitch tool gives you a quick cross-check.
Interior rooms deserve the same care. Check ceiling heights, closets, stairwells and soffits, which are easy to skip. In older New Hampshire houses with nine-foot plaster ceilings, sloped attic bedrooms or odd-shaped additions, a template room size can understate wall and ceiling area by a wide margin. Compare the flooring area to the room dimensions, too; flooring that runs continuously through several rooms often can’t be replaced in just one of them without a visible seam.
Look for waste factors too. Shingles, siding and flooring all need an allowance for cutting; a quantity that equals the bare measured area usually means waste was left out.
Prices and the extras that get dropped
Unit prices come from the software’s regional data. They are a starting point, not a ceiling. After a big regional storm, or in towns where contractors are scarce — much of Coös County, for instance — local bids can run higher. If your contractor’s price differs, ask for a written quote you can put next to the line item.
Then scan for the extras that make a job real:
- Steep and high-roof charges for slopes above roughly 7/12 or two stories.
- Detach and reset for gutters, fixtures, satellite dishes and appliances.
- Content manipulation — moving furniture so work can happen.
- Permits, dumpsters, debris hauling and final cleaning.
- Overhead and profit when several trades must be coordinated.
Depreciation and the coverage columns
Every line shows replacement cost, depreciation and actual cash value. Look at how depreciation was applied. Is the roof’s age right? Is labor being depreciated? Policy wording and New Hampshire law may affect that, so ask an attorney if it’s significant. Make sure recoverable and non-recoverable depreciation are marked correctly, and that items are assigned to the right coverage — a detached garage belongs under other structures, not the dwelling.
What’s missing entirely
The hardest gaps to spot are the lines that aren’t there. Walk the property with the estimate in hand and mark every damaged item you can see. Common omissions in New Hampshire claims include insulation behind wet walls, ice and water shield at the eaves, matching siding on an undamaged elevation, interior painting of whole rooms rather than single walls, and code-required upgrades that may fall under ordinance or law coverage.
What to do with your notes
Once you’ve marked up the estimate, send the adjuster a concise written list of the differences with supporting photos and quotes. Many gaps close through a supplement. If they don’t, an insurer estimate audit puts a figure on the difference, and the appraisal process is there if the gap is large enough. The claim glossary decodes the terms along the way.
